The oddity that was the Flying Deck Cruiser

Between the end of WWI and the beginning of WWII, the U.S. Navy experimented with a number of, ultimately spurned, designs to create a hybrid aviation carrier or cruiser carrier– basically a cruiser hull, engineering suite, and partial main battery, but with an aircraft carrier flight deck and abbreviated hangar. Basically, a light carrier that could escort itself while still outrunning most submarines and battleships of the day– a perfect weapon! Also, there was the prospect of using such designs to thread loopholes in the various naval treaties of the day and getting the most bang for the buck.

Here are some of the concepts, designated as Light Aircraft Carrier (CLV) in the 1930s:

The initial 1931 design, with nine 8″ guns forward and a short, angled deck:

“Proposed Flight Deck Cruiser, type CF”

NHHC S-511-4

Proposed Flight Deck Cruiser Preliminary design plan prepared for the General Board during the final effort to develop a flight deck cruiser (CF). This plan, dated 19 December 1939, is for a 12,000-ton standard displacement ship (14,220-ton trial displacement) with a main battery of three 8/55 guns, a secondary battery of eight 5/38 guns and an aircraft complement of 24 to 36. Ship’s dimensions are waterline length 640′; waterline beam 67′; draft 21′ 8. Powerplant has 100,000 horsepower for a speed of 33 knots. The scale of the original drawings is 1/32 = 1′. The original plan is in the 1939-1944 Spring Styles Book held by the Naval History and Heritage Command. U.S. Naval History and Heritage Command Photograph.

“Proposed Flight Deck Cruiser Preliminary design plan prepared for the General Board during the final effort to develop a flight deck cruiser (CF)”

NHHC#: S-511-9.

This plan, dated 8 December 1939, is for a 12,000-ton standard displacement ship with a main battery of three 8/55 guns and a secondary battery of eight 5/38 guns (six specified in the table). Ship’s waterline length is 640′. The data table leaves other characteristics blank, and the plan is annotated Void – sec. batt arr. changed. The scale of the original drawings is 1/32 = 1′. The original plan is in the 1939-1944 Spring Styles Book held by the Naval History and Heritage Command.

“Proposed Flight Deck Cruiser, CF-2 Preliminary design plan prepared for the General Board during the final effort to develop a flight deck cruiser (CF).”

NHHC S-511-5

This plan, dated 31 January 1940, is for a 12,200-ton standard displacement ship (14,560-ton trial displacement) with a main battery of six 6/47 guns, a secondary battery of four 5/38 guns and an aircraft complement of 36 scout-bombers. Ship’s dimensions are waterline length 640′; waterline beam 67′; draft 22′. The powerplant has 100,000 horsepower for a speed of 33 knots. The scale of the plan and side elevation drawings is 1/32 = 1′. The original plan is in the 1939-1944 Spring Styles Book held by the Naval History and Heritage Command.

As noted by Global Security:

In 1933 Retired Admiral Hilary Jones called the ship “a hermaphrodite – neither a real cruiser nor a real airplane carrier. It has all the weaknesses of both and none of the efficient characteristics of either.” Admiral Joseph M. Reeves, commander-in-chief of the United States Fleet, summed up the case against the flying-deck cruiser in a memo to the General Board dated 08 October 1934 “Each study shows it to be a hybrid type entirely unsuitable as a cruiser or a carrier.” The idea of the flying deck cruiser, though kept alive until 1940, finally disappeared into the land of what-might-have-been.

Of course, the Navy did turn actual cruiser hulls into light carriers, sans armament (the Independence-class), while the Japanese did convert some battleships (Ise and Hyūga) into hybrids during the War.

The Brits even flirted with the idea for their canceled 52,000-ton Lion-class battleships. On 8 January 1941, Rear Admiral Bruce Fraser, Third Sea Lord and Controller of the Navy asked the DNC to work up a hybrid aircraft carrier based on the Lion-class hull, these included versions with a top flight deck and either 6 or 9 BL 16-inch Mk II guns as well as batteries of QF 5.25-inch Mk I dual purpose guns and smaller 2-pdr pom-poms.

The British carrier-battleship pipe dream C. 1943

Further, in the Cold War, the Russians produced the ill-fated and relatively unsuccessful Kiev-class of carrier-battlecruisers while the British billed their Invincible-class “harrier carriers” as through-deck cruisers, a concept that the U.S. experimented with in the 1970s as a “strike cruiser” for VSTOL aircraft, but never got off the ground.

Soviet Kiev-class “Aircraft Carrier” Novorossiysk, more cruiser than flattop.

HMS Invincible with her Sea Harrier airwing, more flattop than cruiser…

The U.S. “strike cruiser” concept of the 1970s, which never grew beyond the model phase.

Tags: ,

About laststandonzombieisland

Let me introduce myself. I am a bit of a conflict junkie. I am fascinated by war and warfare, assassination, personal protection and weaponry ranging from spud guns and flame throwers to thermonuclear bombs and Soviet-trained Ebola monkeys. In short, if it’s violent or a tool to create violence it is kind of my thing. I have written a few thousand articles on the dry encyclopedia side for such websites as Guns.com, University of Guns, Outdoor Hub, Tac-44, History Times, Big Game Hunter, Glock Forum, Firearms Talk.com, and Combat Forums; as well as for print publications like England Expects, and Strike First Strike Fast. Several magazines such as Sea Classics, Military Historian and Collector, Mississippi Sportsman and Warship International have carried my pieces. Additionally I am on staff as a naval consultant and writer for Eye Spy Intelligence Magazine. Currently I am working on several book projects including an alternative history novel about the US-German War of 1916, and a biography of Southern gadfly and soldier of fortune Bennett Doty. My first novel, about the coming zombie apocalypse was released in 2012 by Necro Publications and can be found at Amazon.com as was the prequel, Chimera-44. I am currently working on book two of that series: "Pirates of the Zombie Coast." In my day job I am a contractor for the U.S. federal government in what could best be described as the ‘Force Protection’ field. In this I am an NRA-certified firearms, and less-than-lethal combat instructor.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

The Writer in Black

News and views from The Writer in Black

Stephen Taylor WW2 Relic Hunter

World War 2 Historian, Relic Hunter and expert in identification of WW2 relics

USS Gerald R. Ford

Mission Ready, Qualified & Competent, On Time Execution!

The Unwritten Record

Exploring History with the National Archives Special Media Division

Stuff From Hsoi

Writing about whatever interests me, and maybe you.

Louisville Gun

Thoughts and Musings on Gun Control & Crime

Ted Campbell's Point of View

An old soldier's blog, mostly about Conservative politics and our national defence and whatever else might interest me on any given day

CIVILIAN GUNFIGHTER

Identifying the Best Training, Tools, and Tactics for the Armed Civilian!

MountainGuerrilla

Nous Defions!

Under Every Leaf.

A Site for the British Empire 1860-1913

JULESWINGS

Military wings and things

Western Rifle Shooters Association

Stay frosty. Know "who", "why", and "how" for each Communist in your AO. "When" will be apparent.

Meccanica Mekaniikka Mecanică

The Mechanix of Auto, Aviation, Military...pert near anything I feel relates to mechanical things, places, events or whatever I happen to like. Even non-mechanical artsy-fartsy stuff.

Eatgrueldog

Where misinformation stops and you are force fed the truth III

The LBM Blogger

Make Big Noise

Not Clauswitz

The semi-sprawling adventures of a culturally hegemonic former flat-lander and anti-idiotarian individualist who fled the toxic Smug emitted by self-satisfied lotus-eating low-land Tesla-driving floppy-hat-wearing lizadroid-Leftbat Coastal Elite Califorganic eco-tofuistas ~ with guns, off-road moto, boulevardier-moto, moto-guns, snorkeling, snorkel-guns, and home-improvement stuff.

%d bloggers like this: